Skip to stories
All book ideas
The Music Room Has No Inside cover

Original book ideaGothic fiction

The Music Room Has No Inside

A piano restorer hears a recital in a room that measures less than an inch deep. The owner offers her a fortune to tune the instrument without ever opening the door.

Create my bookRead opening

ImagineYourBook writes a fresh draft from this idea.

How it begins

Miriam measured the room from outside, then from the hall, then from the room above.

An inch remained.

Behind the door, a pianist continued playing.

She lowered the tape.

Laurence Bell waited at the foot of the stairs in a dressing gown that cost more than her winter coat.

"Old houses," he said.

"Not that old."

The piece behind the door reached the same passage she had heard on arrival. A descending run, a pause long enough to be deliberate, then a note struck twice.

Miriam did not recognize the composition.

She recognized the problem.

"The third string isn't speaking."

"Can you correct it?"

"Not without seeing the instrument."

He looked displeased, as though she had added a condition to a simple favor.

"There is a panel."

He led her to a narrow opening behind the coat cupboard. Through it she could see the back of an upright piano, inches from the plaster.

The room around the piano should have occupied the stairwell.

The stairwell contained Laurence, herself and a runner worn thin by years of ordinary feet.

Miriam put her hand against the instrument's wood.

Warm.

The playing stopped.

For the first time since entering the house, she heard the city outside: a bus changing gear, someone arguing with a lock, the practical life of rooms that knew where they ended.

Then a single note sounded beneath her hand.

A mistake she had made as a student. The wrong interval in an examination nobody here could have attended.

She stepped back.

Laurence closed the panel.

"That will happen," he said.

"Why?"

"The instrument becomes acquainted."

Miriam looked at the locked door.

Underneath it lay a folded concert program, newly pushed into the hall.

She picked it up.

Her name appeared beneath the words final performance.

The date was tomorrow.

Laurence reached for the program.

Miriam folded it into her case before he could touch her.

"Who else," she asked, "have you asked to make it perfect?"

Your idea. Your book.

Keep the spark. Change anything.

Create my book

Created with ImagineYourBook. Free to use as inspiration.

Outline and characters

Develop this idea

An impossible-room gothic gains power from professional skepticism. Let Miriam test measurements and acoustics before admitting the discrepancy. The music can carry clues through repetitions, pauses and mistakes without quoting a real composition. Laurence needs a concrete interest in keeping the performance intact. For your version, use another skilled listener and another kind of inaccessible work. Preserve a human account of wrongdoing while allowing the room's final physical fact to resist a complete explanation.

  1. Miriam measures a music room that should be an inch deep
  2. A recital continues behind its locked door
  3. Laurence demands tuning through a sealed service panel
  4. Miriam recognizes deliberate gaps in the instrument's response
  5. Old programs reveal performers erased from the credited recital
  6. The room begins reproducing Miriam's private practice mistakes
  7. Laurence admits the recording concealed another musician's death
  8. Miriam refuses a perfect tuning that would make the false performance permanent
  9. She opens the room during a gathering of the surviving performers
  10. The recital ends, leaving one note sounding from an instrument with no strings
Characters
  • Miriam Sato, 45. Piano restorer hired to tune an impossible room
  • Laurence Bell, 64. House owner preserving a recital he refuses to attend
Series possibilities
  • Miriam is offered an instrument whose repairs appear in her handwriting before she makes them.

Make it your kind of story.

More options

Your book starts fresh from this premise.