Skip to stories
All book ideas
All the People We Could Afford cover

Original book ideaDystopian fiction

All the People We Could Afford

A census analyst in a privately managed town uncovers an algorithm that quietly deletes residents from service budgets before they leave, creating the departures it claims to predict.

Create my bookRead opening

ImagineYourBook writes a fresh draft from this idea.

How it begins

The town had budgeted for Marcus Bell to leave in March.

It was November, and he was still there.

Elena found the discrepancy while reconciling water usage against the population forecast. His household consumed water, produced waste and sent a child to school. In the service model, it had already become an empty address.

She visited during her lunch break.

Marcus answered wearing a coat indoors. The heating allowance had been reduced in February. The bus stop closed in April. By June, the nearest clinic no longer accepted appointments from his postcode.

"They keep saying we're moving," he said.

"Are you?"

"We're trying not to."

Elena looked at the packing boxes stacked beside the wall. He followed her glance.

"Those are from when we arrived. I never found somewhere else to put them."

Back at the office, she traced the forecast. The model predicted departure from missed payments, irregular employment and low participation in company events. Once a household crossed the threshold, services were reduced to avoid spending on residents expected to leave.

When they eventually left, the prediction was counted as correct.

Elena opened the accuracy report she had helped prepare. The headline figure had won her department a bonus. Beneath it lay thousands of departures treated as confirmation, with no field for what the town had withdrawn first.

Her manager stopped by the desk.

"Good news. The next forecast needs fewer school places."

Through the window, Elena could see the bus shelter nearest Marcus's street. Its route map had been removed, leaving a clean rectangle on the glass.

She asked for the dates of every service reduction in the last two years.

"That's operational data," her manager said.

"Yes."

"You're reviewing predictions."

Elena turned the screen toward him.

"I think we're reviewing instructions."

For the first time since joining the department, she left the bonus report open where everyone passing could see the assumptions beneath the result.

Your idea. Your book.

Create my book

Created with ImagineYourBook. Free to use as inspiration.

Outline and characters

Develop this idea

Make the feedback loop visible through a simple sequence: predicted departure, service reduction, actual departure, claimed success. Elena's complicity in the accuracy report gives the discovery personal weight. Residents need varied preferences, including the right to leave, so reform restores choice rather than trapping people for a better statistic. The technical explanation should remain accessible and tied to concrete losses. End with changed decision rules and ongoing scrutiny, not a promise that a revised model can eliminate political choices.

  1. Elena finds residents consuming services after the model has already classified their addresses as empty.
  2. Marcus describes reductions that have made staying increasingly difficult.
  3. The model's celebrated accuracy includes departures caused by its own budget decisions.
  4. Management separates operational data from forecasts to avoid examining the feedback loop.
  5. Elena works with residents and an independent reviewer to reconstruct the sequence of cuts and departures.
  6. Some residents already want to leave and resist being used to justify compulsory retention.
  7. The challenge focuses on restoring choices and services rather than proving everyone should stay.
  8. A public review demonstrates the self-fulfilling mechanism and invalidates the claimed accuracy measure.
  9. The town restores affected allocations and subjects future reductions to current verified occupancy and appeal.
  10. Marcus chooses whether to remain after services return, while Elena's department learns to report uncertainty without turning it into a command.
Characters
  • Elena Ruiz, 38. Census analyst employed by a privately managed town
  • Marcus Bell, 45. Resident whose household has disappeared from service forecasts
Series possibilities
  • A companion story follows another managed town whose success metric conceals the behavior it creates.

Add your twist

More options