Skip to stories
All book ideas
We Agreed to Forget Her cover

Original book ideaPsychological thriller

We Agreed to Forget Her

Three adult siblings hire a family historian to reconcile their inheritance accounts, only to find that each has independently paid someone to remove the same woman from the records.

Create my bookRead opening

ImagineYourBook writes a fresh draft from this idea.

How it begins

Three invoices lay on Helen's desk, each paying to remove the same woman.

The instructions differed. The eldest sibling called her a clerical error. The middle sibling described an intrusion. Marcus, the youngest, had written only: Please leave this out of the family account.

None knew the others had paid.

Helen had been hired to reconcile inheritance records, not make a family more comfortable with itself. She arranged the invoices by date and called a meeting.

They arrived separately, although all three were staying in the same house.

"Who was Rose?" Helen asked.

The eldest reached for his tea. His sister looked at the door. Marcus stared at the photograph Helen had placed in the center of the table.

Rose stood behind them at a summer picnic, holding a plate nobody had taken. She was perhaps thirty, dressed for work while everyone else wore holiday clothes. On the back, someone had written her first name and then rubbed at it until the paper thinned.

"A helper," the eldest said.

"A friend of our mother's," said his sister.

Marcus said nothing.

Helen turned over a wage ledger. Rose had been paid from an account that later became the principal asset of the estate. The payments continued for two years after the date the family claimed she left.

"I need her surname."

The sister pushed her chair back.

"This is exactly why we asked you. To settle things."

"I can't settle a record by removing the person it concerns."

Outside, a gardener started a mower. The familiar noise seemed to make the room smaller.

Marcus finally touched the photograph.

"She wasn't holding a plate for us," he said.

His brother told him to stop.

Marcus looked at Helen.

"She was waiting for someone to make room."

Helen wrote the sentence down exactly, leaving space beneath it for the name they still had not given her.

Your idea. Your book.

Create my book

Created with ImagineYourBook. Free to use as inspiration.

Outline and characters

Develop this idea

Give each sibling a distinct motive, memory and degree of responsibility. Rose should emerge through work, relationships and choices rather than functioning only as a revelation. Separate financial correction from public disclosure: truthful accounting need not expose every private detail. Helen can insist on evidence while recognizing the limits of her commission. The final history should preserve disagreement where the record cannot settle it, offering an honest outcome instead of a single confession that explains every childhood event.

  1. Helen discovers three independent payments to erase Rose from the family history.
  2. The siblings give incompatible accounts of her role.
  3. Wage and property records suggest Rose contributed money to the estate's main asset.
  4. Each sibling concealed a different uncomfortable memory rather than coordinating one explanation.
  5. Marcus reveals Rose was their mother's partner and a sustained caregiver.
  6. The eldest fears a property claim while the sister fears exposing their mother's private life.
  7. Helen locates Rose's surviving correspondence through a named executor, not a secret trove that answers everything.
  8. The letters establish a financial agreement the estate omitted and Rose's wishes about public disclosure.
  9. The siblings correct the inheritance account while respecting the limits Rose requested.
  10. Helen completes a history that records her name and contribution without pretending the family agrees about the past.
Characters
  • Helen Price, 51. Family historian
  • Marcus Vale, 45. Youngest of three siblings settling an inheritance
Series possibilities
  • Helen takes another commission in which conflicting family memories conceal an actionable omission.

Add your twist

More options