Skip to stories
All book ideas
Please Water the Evidence cover

Original book ideaCozy mystery

Please Water the Evidence

A garden judge disappears from the village show. The winning planter arrives with instructions to water the evidence.

Create my bookRead opening

ImagineYourBook writes a fresh draft from this idea.

How it begins

The winning window box was the only entry at the flower show that came with a threat.

Bea read the note twice. It didn't say what would happen if she failed to water the evidence. It did say to start at the end nearest the mint, which was the sort of unnecessary instruction Jonah put on a note when he thought the rest of it might be too surprising.

The box was full of damp earth and six stringy plants. There were two sweet peas fighting over a single cane. Next to the mint was a label shaped like the head of a duck. She could hardly blame the show committee for giving it the prize. There had been no other entries in the section for vegetables grown in a vehicle.

"Is that from Jonah?" asked the woman arranging the certificates.

"Have you seen him?"

"He hasn't judged the beans."

This was worse than it sounded. Last year Jonah had judged the beans after a wasp got into his shirt. He had asked the person holding the scorecard to keep writing while he went to take the shirt off.

Bea carried the box to the sink at the back of the hall. A paper cup stood on the draining board. She filled it and poured a narrow stream into the earth by the mint. The water settled around the duck label and the wood darkened. A line appeared in the grain. At first it looked like a crack. Then it made a turn, and she recognized the odd little corner where the village green ran round the back of a house that no longer stood.

She had seen that corner on one other map, in a cabinet at the deeds office. Someone had tried to sell the green seventeen years ago. Her father had lent the committee a table to spread the original papers on.

The woman with the certificates came over to look.

"Will you put it back before the mayor comes?"

Bea put her thumb over the duck. "I might need a saucer."

Your idea. Your book.

Create my book

Created with ImagineYourBook. Free to use as inspiration.

Outline and characters

Develop this idea

Put the odd instruction on the page before interpreting it. The garden should generate clues through characters' knowledge and choices, and the contest should offer reasons for ordinary lies. Establish who owns the green and what a hearing can actually decide early in the draft. Let a clue point Bea toward a person and a decision rather than mechanically writing the solution for her.

  1. Bea finds the instruction in a prize entry.
  2. She learns Jonah missed a meeting on the land transfer.
  3. Water brings hidden patterns out on plant tags.
  4. The patterns lead to a map laid out in a show table.
  5. A competitor lies about taking a tag for a personal reason.
  6. Bea finds Jonah's hiding place empty and his witness safe.
  7. The reclaimed tag makes an old legal claim legible.
  8. Bea asks the exhibitors to verify the map's plantings.
  9. Jonah appears at the hearing instead of letting Bea rely on clues alone.
  10. The green remains public and the garden show awards a new prize.
Characters
  • Bea Adler, 42. florist and reluctant judge's substitute
  • Jonah Bell, 63. missing garden-show judge and amateur local historian
Series possibilities
  • Another show's anonymously entered bouquet points to a bricked-up doorway.

Add your twist

More options