Skip to stories
All book ideas
A Trophy for the Rough Draft cover

Original book ideaPractical nonfiction

A Trophy for the Rough Draft

Ask a question a first reader can answer and leave with a revision you can actually try.

Create my bookRead sample

ImagineYourBook writes a fresh draft from this idea.

Introduction

Ben put five copies of his story on the library table. By the end of the meeting it had seventeen fewer commas and exactly the same ending.

The ending was what he needed help with. A woman carried a sealed box home from a bus station and put it in the middle of her bed. Ben wanted her to leave the box unopened because she had finally stopped waiting for the person who sent it. Mae thought the box must contain a second box. She was waiting for the next page.

"Would you open it?" Ben asked.

"By now I would have opened it at the bus station," Mae said.

That was the useful answer. Somewhere before the last page, the story had asked her to care about what was in the box. It had not given her much reason to care whether the woman needed to know.

Before you ask somebody to read or look at a rough piece, choose one decision you have not yet made. Tell them what stage the work is at. Ask what they noticed, expected or wanted to see at a specific point. A good first question would be "What did you expect her to do when she got home?" The answer comes from the reader's experience and leaves the writer with the job of deciding what to change.

You can also ask which parts should stay. A clear answer about what has already landed can save a revision from erasing the piece's best moment.

Ben kept the box. In the next draft he added a brief conversation at the station, in which the woman decided to take the last bus anyway. He wanted to see whether that choice shifted what the reader was waiting for. He brought two pages to the next meeting and asked just one question.

Mae said she still wondered about the box. This time she cared who got on the bus.

Your idea. Your book.

Create my book

Created with ImagineYourBook. Free to use as inspiration.

Chapter plan

Develop this idea

Show feedback at the scene level so readers can see the difference between fixing words and diagnosing confusion. Include the actual question the maker asks, the answer they get and the small change they test. Use examples outside fiction as well. Give the reader permission to keep a deliberate choice, while asking what evidence would help them decide whether the choice is working.

  1. Show the pile of comma corrections on an unfinished story.
  2. Define what stage a draft has reached.
  3. Choose one question a reader can answer from the work.
  4. Write context without telling the reader what to feel.
  5. Collect independent reactions before discussion.
  6. Translate broad praise or criticism into observations.
  7. Separate a diagnosis from the reader's preferred fix.
  8. Test one revision against the original intent.
  9. Handle contradictory feedback respectfully.
  10. Build a reusable feedback note for several media.
Series possibilities
  • A guide to organizing a critique group without letting anyone dominate.

Add your twist

More options